During their strategy off-site, the executives at a global retail organization turn their attention away from the strategic plan to address a thorny issue. A junior employee has started vociferously criticizing, in meetings and on Slack, the organization’s commitment to sustainability objectives. The executives’ conversation has been precipitated by months of behind-the-scenes questioning by this person and others. In fact, senior leaders are concerned that this group is on the verge of speaking up publicly about their disappointment, highlighting what they perceive to be a gap between what the company espouses and what it actually practices. Within the executive team there is a divide: Some want to shut the employee down while others want to invite them into the strategic discussion.